Archives Posts
New Data on the Attribution of Mindedness

Science have published an article by Heather Gray, Kurt gray and Daniel Wegner on their research into the attribution of mindedness [Synopsis available at Kurt Gray’s Web site]. The research was based on results from an online survey of 2040 people. The participants ‘averaged 30 years of age and were modally female, white, unmarried, Christian, Democrat, and with some college education’. The survey required the participants to make
… 78 pairwise comparisons on five-point scales of 13 characters for one of 18 mental capacities (e.g., capacity to feel pain) or for one of six personal judgments (e.g., “which character do you like more?”). The characters included seven living human forms (7-week-old fetus, 5-month-old infant, 5-year-old girl, adult woman, adult man, man in a persistent vegetative state, and the respondent him- or herself), three nonhuman animals (frog, family dog, and wild chimpanzee), a dead woman, God, and a sociable robot (Kismet).
Factor analysis reduced the eighteen dimensions of the survey to two, generalised as ‘experience’ and ‘agency’ (see diagram above).
Gray, H.M., Gray, K., Wegner, D.M. (2007) “Dimensions of Mind Perception”. Science 315(5812) p. 619. doi: 10.1126/science.1134475























